QUESTIONS?
How to Choose an Executor
Our team is here to answer your questions and help you protect your legacy. If you’d like guidance tailored to your situation, schedule a time to talk with us.
Get StartedHow to Choose an Executor
Picking an executor is one of the most important decisions you'll make when writing your will. This person will handle your final affairs after you're gone. They'll pay your bills, distribute your assets, and deal with legal paperwork. It's a big responsibility, so you want to choose wisely.
What Does an Executor Actually Do?
Before comparing potential candidates, let's understand what you're asking someone to do. An executor handles everything from filing your will in court to closing your social media accounts. They'll inventory your assets, pay debts and taxes, and distribute what's left to your beneficiaries. Think of them as the project manager for wrapping up your life's business. This role requires significant time commitment, often spanning months or even years depending on the complexity of your estate.
Family Member vs. Friend vs. Professional
You have three main options when choosing an executor. Each has pros and cons worth considering carefully:
Family Members
Pros: They know you well and care deeply about your wishes. They're usually available and won't charge fees. Family members often have emotional investment in doing things right. They understand your family dynamics and personal relationships better than outsiders.
Cons: They might lack experience with legal and financial matters. Family dynamics can create conflicts that complicate the process. Grief might make it harder for them to handle business decisions objectively, especially when dealing with sensitive family heirlooms or contested assets.
Close Friends
Pros: Friends often know your wishes without family drama getting in the way. They might be more objective than relatives when making difficult decisions. You can choose someone whose judgment you really trust without worrying about sibling rivalries or old family grudges affecting their performance.
Cons: They have no legal obligation to your family after you're gone. Friends might move away or drift apart over time, making them unavailable when needed. They still might lack the necessary skills for complex financial or legal matters.
Professional Executors
Pros: Lawyers, accountants, or trust companies have extensive experience and specialized knowledge. They handle everything objectively without emotional involvement that could cloud judgment. They understand legal requirements, deadlines, and complex tax implications that might overwhelm inexperienced executors.
Cons: They charge substantial fees that reduce your estate's value for beneficiaries. They don't know you personally or understand family dynamics and relationships. Professional executors might feel impersonal to your loved ones during an already difficult time.
Key Qualities to Compare
When evaluating potential executors, compare them across these essential qualities that determine success:
Trustworthiness
This is absolutely non-negotiable under any circumstances. Your executor will have access to everything you own, from bank accounts to personal belongings. They need absolute integrity and proven reliability. Ask yourself: Would I trust this person with my bank accounts right now? Have they handled money responsibly in their own life? Have they ever given you reason to question their honesty or judgment?
Availability and Location
Being an executor takes considerable time, especially in the first few months after death. Someone who travels constantly for work might not be ideal for this demanding role. Geographic proximity helps too, since many tasks require local presence. An executor in another state faces extra complications, higher costs, and potential legal hurdles that could delay the entire process significantly.
Organizational Skills
Executor duties involve lots of paperwork, strict deadlines, and countless details that must be tracked carefully. Compare candidates based on how they handle their own affairs day-to-day. Is their desk organized? Do they pay bills on time and keep good records? These seemingly small traits matter more than you might think when managing complex estate administration.
Age and Health
Choose someone likely to outlive you and be mentally and physically capable when needed. Your 85-year-old parent might not be the best choice if you're 60 years old. Consider both current physical health and mental capacity for handling complex tasks under emotional stress during difficult family circumstances.
Financial Understanding
Executors regularly deal with investments, taxes, and asset valuation issues. They don't need to be financial experts, but basic financial literacy helps tremendously. Someone who's never balanced a checkbook or managed investments might struggle with estate accounting requirements and tax filings that could have serious legal consequences if handled incorrectly.
Understanding the Relationship Between Wills and Trusts
When choosing an executor, it's important to understand how your will fits into your broader estate plan. Many people wonder about the difference between a will and a trust, especially when considering whether to use both documents together. If you're also considering a trust as part of your estate planning strategy, you might want to explore what is a pour-over will, which can work alongside a trust to ensure all your assets are properly managed.
Real Example: Sarah's Decision Process
Sarah had three potential executors in mind after careful consideration. Her sister was loving and well-intentioned but notoriously disorganized and lived across the country in California. Her best friend was local, highly capable, and detail-oriented but had never handled anything legal before and felt intimidated by the responsibility. Her accountant was experienced with estate matters but expensive and didn't know her family dynamics or personal values.
Sarah chose her friend as primary executor and her accountant as backup after extensive deliberation. She reasoned that her friend cared most about her wishes and could hire professional help when needed for complex matters. The accountant provided security and expertise if her friend couldn't serve or needed technical assistance with tax filings or legal requirements.
Co-Executors: Sharing the Load
Sometimes appointing two executors makes perfect sense for complex estates. You might pair a family member's personal knowledge with a professional's technical expertise. Or choose two siblings to prevent hurt feelings and family conflicts. Co-executors can divide responsibilities based on their individual strengths and availability.
But co-executors must agree on all major decisions, which can significantly slow things down. They might have different approaches or priorities that create conflict and confusion. Only choose co-executors if you're completely confident they'll work well together and communicate effectively during stressful situations.
Special Considerations for Complex Estates
If your estate includes business interests, multiple properties, or significant investments, your testator responsibilities become more complex. In these cases, you might want to consider someone with business experience or financial expertise. Complex estates often benefit from professional executors who understand corporate structures, tax implications, and asset valuation requirements that can significantly impact your beneficiaries' inheritance.
Having the Important Conversation
Always ask before naming someone as executor - this isn't optional. Explain what's involved in detail and why you chose them specifically. This conversation prevents unpleasant surprises and lets people decline gracefully if they can't commit fully. It also helps your chosen executor prepare mentally and practically for their eventual responsibilities, including understanding your wishes and locating important documents.
During this conversation, discuss your estate's complexity, your family dynamics, and any potential challenges they might face. Be honest about difficult family members or complicated assets. The more they understand upfront, the better prepared they'll be to handle their duties effectively and in accordance with your wishes.
Backup Plans Matter More Than You Think
Name at least one alternate executor in your will, though two backups are even better. People move to different states, become ill, or change their minds about taking on this responsibility. Having multiple backups prevents court-appointed administrators who don't know you, your family, or your wishes from making decisions about your estate's distribution.
When to Reconsider Your Choice
Life changes, and so should your executor choice when necessary. Major life events like marriage, divorce, death of your chosen executor, or significant changes in their circumstances should prompt you to reconsider. Review your choice every few years during routine estate plan updates to ensure it still makes sense given current circumstances and relationships.
Making Your Final Choice
The best executor combines absolute trustworthiness with practical capability and genuine care for your wishes. They care deeply about your intentions but can make tough decisions objectively when needed. They're well-organized, readily available, and likely to outlive you by many years. Most importantly, they're genuinely willing to take on this significant responsibility and see it through to completion.
Remember, you can change executors by updating your will whenever circumstances warrant it. If relationships change, better options emerge, or your chosen executor's situation changes, don't hesitate to make necessary adjustments. Your executor choice is far too important to leave to chance, outdated thinking, or unchanged circumstances from years past.
Take substantial time to really compare your options carefully and thoroughly. Consider each person's individual strengths and potential limitations with complete honesty. The right choice will give you tremendous peace of mind knowing your final affairs are in capable, trustworthy hands that will honor your wishes and treat your beneficiaries with respect and fairness.
