QUESTIONS?
How to Choose a Trustee
Our team is here to answer your questions and help you protect your legacy. If you’d like guidance tailored to your situation, schedule a time to talk with us.
Get StartedHow to Choose a Trustee
Choosing a trustee is one of the most important decisions you'll make when creating a trust. This person will manage your assets and carry out your wishes. Think of them as the captain of your financial ship. You want someone reliable, honest, and capable of handling the responsibility.
The trustee has significant power over your trust. They'll make investment decisions, distribute money to beneficiaries, and handle all the paperwork. Getting this choice right protects your family and ensures your wishes are followed. When creating what does a living trust do, understanding the trustee's role becomes even more critical since they'll be managing your assets both during your lifetime and after.
Key Qualities to Look For
Your ideal trustee should have several important characteristics. These qualities will help them succeed in managing your trust effectively.
Trustworthiness is everything. Your trustee will have access to all your assets. They need to be someone you trust completely. Look for people who have always been honest in their dealings with you and others. This becomes particularly important when dealing with substantial assets or when minor beneficiaries are involved.
Financial knowledge matters. Managing a trust involves investments, taxes, and complex financial decisions. Your trustee doesn't need to be a financial expert, but they should understand basic money management. They should also be willing to work with professionals when needed. Consider whether they've successfully managed their own finances or have experience with investment portfolios.
Availability is crucial. Being a trustee takes time and attention. Your chosen person needs to be available to handle trust matters promptly and efficiently. Someone who travels constantly or has overwhelming responsibilities might not be the best choice, especially during critical decision-making periods.
Good judgment is essential. Trustees make many decisions on behalf of beneficiaries. Look for someone who makes thoughtful, balanced decisions. They should be able to handle conflicts fairly and reasonably. Past behavior often predicts future performance, so consider how they've handled difficult situations before.
Communication skills help everyone. Your trustee will need to communicate with beneficiaries, attorneys, and financial advisors regularly. Choose someone who communicates clearly and keeps good records. Poor communication often leads to misunderstandings and family disputes that could have been avoided.
Different Trustee Options
You have several options when choosing a trustee. Each type has advantages and disadvantages to consider carefully.
Family members are often the first choice. They know your family dynamics and care about your beneficiaries. Your spouse, adult children, or siblings might be good candidates. However, family members might lack financial expertise or struggle with family conflicts. They may also find it emotionally difficult to make tough decisions about distributions.
Close friends can be excellent trustees. They often know you well and understand your values without the emotional baggage that family relationships sometimes carry. A longtime friend who's good with money might be perfect. Just make sure they're willing to take on this long-term responsibility and won't let friendship cloud their judgment.
Professional trustees include banks, trust companies, and financial institutions. They have expertise and won't disappear or become unavailable. They're also neutral parties who won't play favorites among beneficiaries. The downside is they charge fees and might not know your family personally. However, their experience with survivorship planning and tax issues can be invaluable.
Attorneys or accountants you trust can serve as trustees effectively. They have professional expertise and understand legal requirements thoroughly. However, they also charge fees and might retire or change careers. Consider whether they have specific trust administration experience beyond their general professional qualifications.
Important Considerations
Several factors should influence your trustee selection. Think through these carefully before making your final decision.
Age and health matter. Choose someone who's likely to outlive the trust or at least serve for many years. A trustee who's much older than you might not be available when needed most. Consider their health and energy levels too, especially if the trust will require active management for decades.
Location can be important. While trustees can serve from anywhere, local trustees are often more convenient for hands-on management. They can easily meet with beneficiaries and handle local matters. However, don't let distance prevent you from choosing the best person. Modern technology makes remote trust administration much more feasible than in the past.
Willingness is essential. Always ask before naming someone as trustee. Being a trustee is a big responsibility that some people don't want or feel qualified to handle. Make sure your chosen person is willing and able to serve. Discuss the time commitment and responsibilities involved so they can make an informed decision.
Potential conflicts should be considered. Think about relationships between your trustee and beneficiaries. A trustee who has conflicts with beneficiaries might struggle to serve effectively. Consider family dynamics and potential jealousies. Sometimes an outside trustee can actually preserve family relationships by removing the burden of difficult decisions from family members.
Compensation expectations vary. Professional trustees always charge fees, typically 1-2% of trust assets annually. Family members might serve for free or expect reasonable compensation. Discuss this upfront to avoid misunderstandings and potential resentment later.
Co-Trustees and Successor Trustees
You don't have to choose just one trustee. Multiple trustees can share responsibilities and provide checks and balances.
Co-trustees serve together simultaneously. You might pair a family member with a professional trustee to get the best of both worlds. The family member provides personal knowledge while the professional handles investments and legal matters. However, co-trustees must agree on decisions, which can slow things down and sometimes create gridlock.
Successor trustees step in when the original trustee can't serve anymore. Always name backup trustees in case your first choice becomes unavailable. Consider naming multiple successors in order of preference. This planning is just as important as choosing your primary trustee since successor trustees often serve when beneficiaries need the most support.
Red Flags to Avoid
Certain characteristics make someone unsuitable as a trustee. Watch out for these warning signs.
Financial problems are a major red flag that cannot be ignored. Someone who can't manage their own money shouldn't manage yours. Avoid people with bankruptcy, excessive debt, or poor spending habits. Their financial struggles could tempt them to misuse trust assets.
Substance abuse issues disqualify potential trustees completely. Addiction affects judgment and reliability in ways that could devastate your trust. Choose someone with a clean track record and stable lifestyle habits.
Legal troubles indicate poor judgment. Avoid people with criminal records or ongoing legal problems. Your trustee should be above reproach since they'll be handling significant assets and making important decisions for your beneficiaries.
Family troublemakers shouldn't be trustees under any circumstances. Someone who creates drama or plays favorites will cause problems among beneficiaries. Choose peacekeepers, not conflict creators, especially in complex family situations.
Special Situations
Some circumstances require extra consideration when choosing trustees.
Minor children as beneficiaries need trustees who understand child development and educational planning. The trustee should make age-appropriate decisions about distributions for education, health, and support. They should also understand how to balance current needs with long-term wealth preservation for the children's futures.
Special needs beneficiaries require trustees who understand government benefit programs thoroughly. The wrong distribution could disqualify someone from essential benefits like Medicaid or SSI. Consider trustees with specific special needs trust experience or willingness to work closely with special needs attorneys.
Business interests in your trust need trustees with business experience and understanding. Managing a business is different from managing investments and requires different skills. Consider whether the business should be sold or continued, and choose trustees accordingly.
Blended families create complex dynamics that require careful navigation. Choose a trustee who can be fair to all beneficiaries, including stepchildren and children from different relationships. Sometimes an outside trustee works best in these situations to avoid the appearance of favoritism.
Legal and Tax Implications
Understanding the legal framework is crucial when selecting a trustee. Different types of trusts have varying requirements and implications.
When comparing living vs. irrevocable living trusts, the trustee selection becomes even more critical since irrevocable trusts are harder to modify later. Your trustee choice in an irrevocable grantor trust will have long-lasting consequences that are difficult to change.
Tax implications also matter significantly. Professional trustees understand the complex tax filing requirements and can help minimize tax burdens on both the trust and beneficiaries. They know when to make distributions for tax efficiency and how to handle investment decisions with tax consequences in mind.
Making Your Final Decision
After considering all factors, make your choice based on your specific situation. There's no perfect trustee, but there's likely a best choice for your circumstances.
Talk to your potential trustee about your expectations in detail. Explain the trust's purpose and your hopes for how it will operate. Make sure they understand and accept the responsibility fully. Provide them with written guidance about your wishes and values to help guide their future decisions.
Review your trustee choice periodically as circumstances change. People change, and your trust might need different leadership over time. You can usually change trustees if your trust is revocable, but changes to irrevocable trusts require more complex procedures.
Consider creating a comprehensive estate plan that includes more than just your trust. Understanding what do I need besides a living trust helps ensure all aspects of your estate planning work together harmoniously.
Conclusion
Choosing a trustee is a personal decision that depends on your unique circumstances and family dynamics. Focus on finding someone trustworthy, capable, and available for the long term. Consider professional help if your trust is complex or valuable. Remember that you can use co-trustees or change trustees if needed. The right trustee will honor your wishes and protect your beneficiaries for years to come, making this one of the most important decisions in your estate planning process.
